[quote name=\'Matt Ottinger\' post=\'127042\' date=\'Aug 11 2006, 10:06 AM\']
Two of your three examples are all-out revivals. The tricky one is WWW/Challengers because each show has received votes and a couple of people included both shows on their list. I've decided to count them as the same show, which seems to be the fairest thing to do, and in line with the producer's intent. (I know Ronnie Greenberg. Ronnie Greenberg is a friend of mine. And you, sir, are no Ronnie Greenberg.)
If anybody picks He said/She Said (out of 1,290 selections so far, no one has) I'll add it to Tattletales. As for Small Talk (which actually did get a vote), it's just not the same show as Child's Play. Once you start getting into similar themes, then you quickly head down a slippery slope that ends with every show that has returning champions and/or buzzers being lumped in with Winner Take All.
[/quote]
Hey, it's your list, but i'm not sure i agree with lumping hs/ss with tattletales, and especially WWW with challengers...yes, they were revivals, but there were enough rule differences that made them quite different.... I liked WWW a LOT more than Challengers....
but hey, again, it's your list, and your rules....
btw, has there actually been a vote for "Small Talk"? geez.