Then let me explain in terms even a "ninny" can understand
I was asked two different questions
1. What are the remaining 13 shows on a list of 50 from GSN?
I am stuck with what they all the shows they have already listed. The question is should the Newlywed Game the Dating Game be on a list of the 50 greatest games ever? Yes, they definitely should and they were on mine at 41 and 42.
Should they be on the list of the top 13? no, they should not. And I wish they were not. I wish they were where they belonged on the GSN list so one could put The Amazing Race on there and it would not have to "replace" them. Remember in this question I was asked; I did not have the option of moving Dating and Newlywed down.
So a better show had to be left off so that it would not "replace" two lesser deserving shows that have to be on a list of the 50 greatest somewhere.
Give me the entire list of 50. "Should" The Amazing Race "replace" The Newlywed Game on the list of 50? No, It should not, instead it should replace Dog Eat Dog and Newlywed Game should move down to that spot.(but I did not have that option in this question)
In this senerio, is opposite is also possible and true. The Newlywed Game "should" not "replace" The Amazing Race on a list of the 50 greatest game shows.
In either case, if someone gave me a list 50 shows and asked "should" you replace on this list The Newlywed Game with The Amazing Race? The correct answer is no. It "should" not "replace" it. And visa versa.
In either case, if someone had asked me the follow-up question; "What 'should' GSN have done to put the Amazing Race on the list if 50?", which no one did, I would have answered, "It should have taken Dog Eat Dog, Studs, Love Connection off the list moved Dating Game or Newlywed Game down and put The Amazing Race in the top 10"
Think about this way if someone put together a list of the 50 greatest shows without Password and then asked you "should" I "replace" Pyramid with Password? Of the correct answer is no. There are lots of ways to include both.
Don't blame me because you did not ask the right question.
2. I was asked what are the 50 greatest game shows ever? I gave that answer.
I was not asked either time what "should" be on list of the 13 greatest game shows? If I had been I would not have answered The Newlywed Game or The Dating Game.
The first piece of advice I give my clients, on the stand, answer the question you are asked and ONLY the question you are asked. I did that both times.