[quote name=\'Robert Hutchinson\' post=\'134799\' date=\'Oct 17 2006, 09:56 PM\']
[quote name=\'Jay Temple\' post=\'134798\' date=\'Oct 17 2006, 09:48 PM\']In the New York era, at least, the list did have to be accurate, because I recall "Randy Newman" being buzzed as a cule for SHORT PEOPLE. (He's six feet tall.) You could also say that buzzing "a diaper" for THINGS YOU PAMPER is a requirement of accuracy.[/quote]
I think you missed part of my description:
"as long as they weren't trying to sneak the answer by in a non-list way"
Saying "Randy Newman" for SHORT PEOPLE is not merely a misunderstanding about the man's height; it's an attempt to communicate the idea of "short people" without listing short people.[/quote]
From my erratic memory file: Once, McLean Stevenson was in the winner's circle, and the contestant was giving the clues, and one of the board's panels read: "Short People." That was it. The contestant said, "Midgets," and Stevenson said, "Short people," and ding! that was it. After that, I noticed that whenever the subject reappeared, it read, "Names of Short People."