I wasn't really involved in this forum at the time, so I truly have no idea. For me, the issues were that the Circle was far too easy, the celebrities (for the most part) weren't that good, the music blew, the set blew, the tournaments blew, and I think they could have had far better hosting choices. Really, the only part I liked was toughening up the main game the bit, but the difficulty seemed to flip flop between the main game and the Circle. I don't know what the opinion was here, maybe some of the older members could fill us in, because I am curious as well. I should probably search.