[quote name=\'BMaurice06\' post=\'163975\' date=\'Sep 16 2007, 01:48 PM\']
I wholly agree with you on Drew and the set, but calling Rich a schmuck? Would you have said the same thing about Johnny Olson or Rod Roddy? Give the guy a break!
[/quote]
Would you have said the same things about Jim Perry and the '80s US $otC, or about Tony Barber and the Aussie $otC, that you've said about Rossi Morreale and Temptation? Would you say the same things about Todd Newton that you've said about, well, pretty much every other game show host? Give me a break!
I think the slamming of Rich Fields has been way overdone, and certainly some of it has far less to do with Rich's ability as announcer than the inability of some people to forgive CBS for not hiring Randy West. But people are entitled to their opinions, and the fact that Rich Fields happens to hold the same job that Johnny Olson and Rod Roddy once held does not by definition make him as good as they were. Moreover, you are the last person who should be lecturing others on "giving people a break," given how -- not unlike the portion of criticism of Rich that comes from not being Randy -- you've refused to give Temptation or Rossi Morreale a chance simply because Rossi isn't Todd Newton.
(And before anyone tries to turn this into a Randy vs. Rich war, I'm not touching that debate with a ten-foot pole. I happen to like and respect both gentlemen, and I enjoy listening to both of them work. If that makes me less respectable in the eyes of some folks here, so be it.)