[quote name=\'uncamark\' post=\'181925\' date=\'Mar 19 2008, 11:09 AM\']But those, of course, had the hook of the game being played by various shades of celebrity. Would it work with teams of civilians, especially considering the quality of contestant that seems to be taken by most American game shows these days not named "Jeopardy!"?[/quote]If you find contestants who would do this:
Contestant: "Is it a pie?"
Host: "No, it's not a pie."
Contestant: "It's a pie! I'm sure of it! You're lying!"
Then yes, you have problems. (And I think I remember some sort of sketch show bit built upon that very premise...) It if was done like Inside the Box, where the other contestants are responsible for providing the yeses and noes, then you might have something. (And I don't think it's all that far fetched, given what we have from the thread.)