Johnny Gilbert was and is awesome on "Jeopardy!", a job he's held for a quarter-century now. Isn't he like 88 or 89 years old now? Hard to believe! I remember him announcing on Ruprecht's "Supermarket Sweep" and he was awesome on that too, giving the play by play. I especially loved season 1 when they'd have a person dressed up as a giant carrot, or a can of string beans, blocking and chasing the sweeping contestants throughout the aisles, just hilarious!
Charlie O IS Wheel of Fortune to me. Jack Clark did really well, and I was sad when he died, but I remember Wheel back in '75 and Charlie announcing, and I'm glad he's on the show now too, a perfect fit. I liked his work on the B&E shows too very much, especially HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOT Potato!!!
I agree, Gene Wood sounded very out of place announcing Price is Right back in late 85, early 86. Rod was a perfect fit on that show, and Press Your Luck.
Rich Jeffries, who I did not see mentioned, was like nails on a blackboard to me. I disliked him during the first few weeks on Super Password, and on Rafferty's Blockbusters too. His voice was just too nasally or shrill somehow. He sounds like a very nice guy, but as announcers go, just not up to snuff.
I liked Burton's work on "Price is Right", so-so on "Feud".
Incidentally, I think Don Pardo sounded awesome on the Cullen Price is Right eps, and he sounds exactly the same now as he did over half a century ago, just amazing!
Appropriate to bring up announcers, especially last week in sports, with the death of Harry Kalas, and the retirement of John Madden. Great idea for a topic!