I heard that the original Donnymid pilots resembled both the 1980s CBS Daytime and Syndicated versions far more than the actual series did. Oh, if only Donnymid had actually gone down that route!
Honestly, as many problems as I had with the show, I'll at least give them credit for staying faithful for the most part, esp. compared to the Mark Walberg/Chuck Woolery pilots. The only big difference was 6-in-20, as opposed to the 7-in-30. It was the execution (writing, judging, the anti-climactic tournaments) I had problems with.