My takes in a nutshell...
\ At the risk of being labeled an old fuddy duddy, I didn't recognize the first panelist on Tuesday's debut. Even with that, and a gripe I brought up over the stars being in *rectangles* instead of *squares*, I was surprisingly impressed by the debut.
\ Peter Rosenberg seemed a bit robotic -- asking a civilian player if (s)he (dis)agrees with a particular star's answer seemingly every time.
\ The stakes are alarmingly low compared to MTV's "The Substitute" (either the entire class splits $5000 or one player takes all the money; this as opposed to the $2500 bonus round).
...even with the problems, HHS provided a fun atmosphere. If they can turn negatives into positives going forward, I wouldn't be surprised if this lasted six seasons.