THe episode in question may be the Halloween 1997 episode, with the category "Universal Monsters", which required the players to take the clues in order. I know this because today's(12/18) GSN J! rerun is said episode.
My bad, people... I saw (at least,
I BELIEVE I saw ((8=D)) ) the same episode on GSN Sunday morning (12/14, 9:30 AM PST; the first episode with Bob Harris, just before they broke for the (Teen? College?) Tournament w/ the semis and finals in Washington D.C. and D.C. Power Players Week... Right?) However...
While I remember the "Universal Monsters" category was played, it wasn't the category that had to be selected in order. The "Take In Order" category that the J! board and Matt mentioned was played in the same round. (Now to figure out why GSN aired it again today...)
Esoteric Eric, who once wondered why a St. Louis TV station was running an ad for Your New England Pontiac Dealers for many minutes before realizing he was watching a videotape he recorded in Boston, forgetting to FF through the ads...