Seeing the Convy pilot for the first time begs the question: Why did they decide to shoehorn "Match-Up" into the show when it went to series? They had a perfectly good, self-contained half-hour format as it was. Change the points over to dollars if you want, but either way, it works.
Match Game will never fit properly into a single half hour. Three full rounds is rushed, MG PM had the chance that some of the players match straight away and sit like a log for the rest of the time. On the other hand, you could have the issue of MG'98, where a 1-0 victory plays all of three questions and you have to add a commercial break between the Audience Match and Head to Head, and still stretch.
Match-up allows your contestants to say more than two answers over the course of the show, but it also brings the show to a climactic conclusion in the form of the horse race as the clock winds down, and you either get "Match...and win!" or "Time's up, Green Triangle Guy, you're the champ!" It isn't a
great fix, but after watching I've come to the conclusion that it is slightly better than a coin flip because you still have to make the judgment call.
I thought Bert was fine, I think he should have done
Body Language (since he still gets to ham it up with the celebrities, and fewer chances to give away material), and Tom Kennedy should have hosted
Super Password.