Art was indeed a most underrated television host. I remember watching reruns of Pay Cards (not Super Pay Cards but the original) on WNEW Channel 5 New York. I also have fond memories of watching "The Magnificent Marble Machine", even though it is deemed one of the worst game shows of all time by many game show fans.
Art's signature show was "The Who What or Where" game. I never saw it on TV but did discover it on youtube. A very good show, a pre-cursor to Dick Clark's "The Challengers".
Art sadly was saddled with some bad premises for games, such as "Marble" and "Blank Check". I am surprised Catch Phrase didn't last longer than only 13 weeks.
Bill Cullen had some very solid game shows in "Chain Reaction" and "Blockbusters" just to name a couple, and yet they too did not last very long. I guess without ratings, no matter how solid a game appears to be, it won't last very long.