Unless I am very much mistaken, I am under the impression After Midnight will be a talk show, not a game show. I am a fan of Taylor Tomlinson and I can't see her hosting a game show, but I do think it would be interesting to see her interviewing guests. I am really rooting for her, I think she'll be great.
If you are expecting a program where Taylor Tomlinson sits at a desk and interviews guests, then you are, in fact, very much mistaken. As has been reported many, many times, this program is based on the Comedy Central program
@midnight. There will probably be differences between this and the original show, and we'll find that out soon enough, but
@midnight is usually referred to as a game show. It is a game show in much the same way that
Whose Line Is It Anyway? is a game show. Professional funny people make up funny things on the spot and are awarded points by the host more or less arbitrarily. Some folks might want to argue whether or not that sort of format constitutes what WE typically think of as a "game show," but whatever the show is, it is not a talk show.