I’m curious, Chelsea, where your extremely strong opinion comes from. My understanding is that you have worked at local affiliates. Respectfully, depending upon market size, there’s a bias and not necessarily accurate understandings of the budgets and ROIs. Local time is limited so I doubt any local sales team would be bullish on a show like The Talk especially with low linear ratings.
The reality check is The Talk fills the same car wash need as GMA3 or Access Live, which have comparable ratings. It’s additive to the power they have elsewhere with ET and Colbert. It’s a strategic investment on the network side and my sources—which include plenty of those execs—would strongly suggest that short of another scandal involving talent the plusses of The Talk far exceed the minuses.
NBC affiliates complained for years about Days of Our Lives. Those that could delayed it and some even outright pre-empted it. The network kept renewing it in spite of those protests. It was only after the whole Covid mess and their focus on keeping 10 pm in line that common sense finally won. I was personally involved in the negotiations on the Sony side, and we were consistently stunned at how much we were able to get out of a show that brought virtually nothing but animus to the network.
I strongly suspect the situation at CBS is much the same. I simply do not believe The Gates will ever see the light of day. And I don’t believe they have any better idea for The Talk, including the streaming hour option suggested. NBC did that with their news because it’s a corporate priority. Until the fate of Paramount is determined I don’t believe anyone in charge will care enough to make a dramatic move.