Hmm...
Well, it's kinda funny that you mention wrestling since my roommate loved wrestling and I loved game shows. I would occasionally watch wrestling with him, and all I'd basically do is laugh, especially at the poorly-choreographed matches. He'd occasionally watch game shows with me as well, but he never said anything about it; however, he did ask me how in the world \"Bumper Stumpers\" lasted three years after he watched a few eps. with me.
Anyway, as far as being \"stereotyped,\" I was kinda looked at as a little odd especially since I'm the only one on my campus (and, yes, this is true!) who has a game show tape collection. However, I have noticed that you can always bring up a popular game show and get people talking. Not only that, but a lot of people would watch WOF with me at night.
Even with the people who walked by my dorm room and wondered why I was getting excited over a $20,000 Pyramid episode, though, they would still occasionally stop in and take a gander. So, I was always able to at least find a way to get other people at least somewhat interested in old game shows, if only for a brief moment.
So, in conclusion: I do think I'm stereotyped, but not as bad as a lot of people would think. Mainly, I just get jokes about it from my friends!
Anthony