[quote name=\'jalman\' date=\'Oct 1 2004, 08:02 PM\']Anyways, did anyone feel the show got shakier once Bauman took the mike and threw it to a commercial?
[snapback]59255[/snapback]
[/quote]
Absolutely. I thought the Match Game portion of the show was pretty solid. Maybe not quite up there with the show's mid-70s heyday, but it still ran very smoothly. Gene was still in fine form - again, maybe not in
top form, but he still was himself and seemed to try and make the best of the show. Plus, the absence of Brett, Charles, and other MG regulars probably contributed to the relative lack of rapport.
But indeed, things went downhill once the third round of Match Game ended. First of all, I thought the way they handled the transition from MG to HS was awkward - they should've cut to a commercial after the fee plugs and then done the introduction of the three additional celebrities when they came back. And then the HS portion itself was just so awkward. First of all, what were they thinking hiring Jon Bauman? (I know it's been discussed many times before, but this is my first time seeing him in action.) I almost felt sorry for him because it seemed like he was completely uncomfortable in this position and really didn't seem to have any idea how to go about hosting. (To his credit, though, he did make a pretty good panelist.) The lack of scripted bluffs also really hurt the show, and made for some very lame questions. This part of the show was such a downer coming after the enjoyable Match Game segment.
What seemed like a good idea on paper, and for the first half of the show, was let down by the weak adaption of Hollywood Squares and the ill-advised casting of Bauman as host. As Don said, it really was sad to see Gene and Jon hosting alongside each other, because Gene, even if he wasn't fully into it, still upstaged Jon very easily. Just that awkward closing alone is enough to see the vast difference in hosting quality.
Overall, based on this episode, I'd give the show a 7, because in spite of the weaknesses this show still has a lot going for it - Gene Rayburn's fine hosting, the thoroughly enjoyable Match Game segment, the snazzy set, the awesome theme, and the late Gene Wood, whose announcing fit this show perfectly.