As I do over at animemusicvideos.org, let's give it the ratings treatment here....
(These categories are graded on a scale of 1 to 10, and please forgive me if the ratings are harsh. I am grading this on its own merits, and not trying to compare it to the AMVs I like to watch.)
Originality: Hollywood Squares video. Huey Lewis's \"Hip to be Square\". Kind of expected here. Clips of stars from back in the day. 6.
Capture Quality: Of course most of the stuff is on tape, so of course the quality is going to be suffering. But you make do with what you got. Still, there were some clips that still looked pretty awful even on the video. 6.
Sound: Logical choice for theme of this video. However, if you're going to edit the song to make it shorter, make sure the edits make sense. The music on the whole is very good. 6.
Action Sync and Lip Sync: Lip sync not very relevant, although as far as action sync goes, the cutaways need to me a bit more on the beat and right at certain points in the song. N/A.
Special Effects: None needed, actually. A fade in at the beginning and a fade out at the end is enough. Things kept simple. 7.
Effort: Nice job to put together an interesting GSMV, as it were. A very nice effort put together here. 7.
Re-viewability: Game show otaku will want to watch this a lot. As for me, even though I like the game shows, I'll watch it a few times. 5.
Overall: If you excuse the clip quality and the odd edits in the music, it's a good video. 6.
Good Points: Good music choice, nice blast from the past with the Davidson version of HS.
Bad Points: Clip quality, odd edits, action sync kinda suffers.
In General: Don't get me wrong, this is a good video.
Nice job. Very nice. Very enjoyable 2 minutes of time.
- J