[quote name=\'Robert Hutchinson\' date=\'Aug 27 2005, 05:00 AM\']This I disagree with. You may have caught him on a good day, or one where he didn't have to fill any time. I think he's somewhat competent, and I've certainly seen worse, more wooden, and more annoying (he's a good light-year ahead of Louie Anderson). But after three YEARS of hosting, he still chokes on something so common as building up the reveal for a steal.
[/quote]
I may have. So the question turns to whether he's being hired to be a competent game-show host, or whether he's being hired to be Al Borland. I'm guessing it might be a little closer to the latter. People like Al's character, he's unthreatening, a little naive, and he bumbles somewhat. I think a LOT of people identify with that for whatever reasons.
So maybe we're nitpicking him because we have these expectations of what a game show is supposed to be, and while he doesn't stand up to those, he's being someone that people will nonetheless watch and feel good about.