I dunno why people keep dumping on Survivor like they do. If you don't like it, don't watch. It's not "Nova" or "Antiques Roadshow," and that's OK. I enjoy it for the games each week, and the utter paranoia that sets in around The Merge.
I'm glad I brought back up the Countdown thing. My point was that the pilot was done, and dismissed, and that was all that became of it. There had to be some reason.
As to the cerebral thing, the reason is that it's true. 100%, Mastermind, Fifteen-to-One...the list goes on. They dig the quiz shows. In this country, if you want to see a new one, you get Jeopardy or Millionaire, and Millionaire is only one person against the game, and the "question per hour" ratio isn't as good. Whenever we get a new decent quiz show, something happens and it goes bad- Greed had game mechanics problem you could drive my car through, and the network wanted to go another way; Weakest Link did too many low-level celebrity editions. Nothing gets half-a-chance anymore.
Personally, one series of 65 shows rerun three times a year on GSN just wouldn't do it for me. The game is too good to be treated like that. Would I be thrilled if the game were done, done right and given the proper treatment? Hell yes- I'd go out and get a cable box right then, with Tivo in waiting. But I'm wary because of what has happened to good shows before.
As I've said MANY times before, not every show on television has to target the same young, stupid audience.
I submit "Deal or No Deal." A game that trumpets the fact that you need no knowledge or skill to play the game. And "History IQ" gets shunted off to Saturdays at 6 in the morning. It's just not right. While not every show HAS to cater to that audience, that's the pattern that seems to form here.