The Game Show Forum
The Game Show Forum => The Big Board => Topic started by: Jeremy Nelson on January 31, 2011, 06:45:59 PM
-
So after skimming through another thread where a small debate over the success of panel shows in this day and age is brewing, I wondered who would make great panelists in this day and age. Now I pose the question to you: which star or stars would you choose for an ideal panel show lineup in 2011? Whether you want to choose anybody or people who you'd realistically be able to book, it's up to you.
I'd probably choose NPH, Sherri Shepherd, Betty White, and Ed O Neill- I think Peyton Manning would also be a good fit.
-
LIVE from new york its
WHATS
MY
LINE
with our panel
Ben Stein
Mika brzezinski
jon stewart
neil patrick harris
and heres our host. mo rocca
-
[quote name=\'toetyper\' post=\'256096\' date=\'Jan 31 2011, 08:17 PM\']LIVE from new york its
WHATS
MY
LINE
with our panel
Ben Stein
Mika brzezinski
jon stewart
neil patrick harris
and heres our host. mo rocca[/quote]
I'll have to give you props here: I could see it as a good, dynamic panel.
-
[quote name=\'toetyper\' post=\'256096\' date=\'Jan 31 2011, 07:17 PM\']and heres our host. mo rocca[/quote]
With no disrespect intended for Mr. Rocca, J. Keith van Stratten has done the role on stage very well and could certainly translate it to the video medium.
/And you haven't lived until you've heard Adam Chester's take on "Blister In The Sun."
-
In a general sense, one of the things I would want from my panel-- and one of the things that made the classic ones so great -- is the appearance that this little parlor game is just a diversion for them and isn't their prime source of income or professional distinction. One of the few modern shows to pull that off has been -- of all things -- The Marriage Ref, but even there, none of those A-listers were regulars. Still, for us to thrown out the names of our favorite folks is a somewhat pointless exercise without any real concept of how well they'd work together, how well they'd play the game we had for them, and whether they'd be the slightest bit interested.
-
[quote name=\'Matt Ottinger\' post=\'256115\' date=\'Jan 31 2011, 10:34 PM\']Still, for us to thrown out the names of our favorite folks is a somewhat pointless exercise without any real concept of how well they'd work together, how well they'd play the game we had for them, and whether they'd be the slightest bit interested.[/quote]
Exactly. And in today's TV, where a show is NOT given the time to develop and earn an audience, the show would not have luxury of getting a panel together, letting it play a few weeks, and see how the dynamics went. With the original WML and IGAS, it seemed (yes, I know the reality) that it was a group of people who got together every week to play a game, just as many of us get together on a regular basis to watch football, knit, play poker or discuss books. Even HS - which I consider a panel game on steroids - and MG7x took some time to find the panelists who worked, who knew when to joke and when to play seriously, and so on. (Think: Paula Poundstone on TTTT2K - and I love Paula on "Wait Wait Don't Tell Me") If somebody got the idea to do a 2011 panel show, they had better get their panel ready and well-tested before the first show hits the air/cable.
-
I vote for Adam Strom, Don Howard, Chris Lemon, and Daniel Benfield. Matt Ottinger as host.
-
[quote name=\'Modor\' post=\'256127\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 08:16 AM\']I vote for Adam Strom, Don Howard, Chris Lemon, and Daniel Benfield. Matt Ottinger as host.[/quote]
This would only be complete with Michael Tiller as announcer.
-
[quote name=\'jmangin\' post=\'256129\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 09:08 AM\'][quote name=\'Modor\' post=\'256127\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 08:16 AM\']I vote for Adam Strom, Don Howard, Chris Lemon, and Daniel Benfield. Matt Ottinger as host.[/quote]
This would only be complete with Michael Tiller as announcer.
[/quote]
Hmm..... (http://\"http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31g0YE61PLQ\")
-
[quote name=\'Modor\' post=\'256127\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 08:16 AM\']I vote for Adam Strom, Don Howard, Chris Lemon, and Daniel Benfield. Matt Ottinger as host.[/quote]
Sorry, no. When I become a big, big star and get to produce my own panel show, I'm hiring a good host and putting myself on the panel. Thanks for the offer, though!
-
I'm so glad to not see 'Panel' spelled 'Panal'
-
If I was casting a primetime "What's My Line," here goes.
Kathy Griffin, love her or hate her, was terrific in Brett's seat on the Game Show Marathon's Match Game. She's not afraid to be the foil. Caroline Rhea.
Shatner. Serious, but funny serious. Provided he could play WML better than Password. Or as someone else suggested, Ben Stein. Or heck, Wil Wheaten, since he played J. Keith's version, is younger, and has a funny outlook on the has-been celebrity thing.
Jessica Simpson. Because I like a little eye-candy, and she has to be pretty smart to play that dumb. Or Alyssa Milano, if she could play the game and doesn't pluck her eyebrows. Or Paula Abdul, who may or may not show up drunk. Or Sherry Shepherd, since "The View" gives her some fame and if the game falls apart with the others.
Then I'd have the fourth seat rotate. Craig Ferguson and Neil Patrick Harris, if CBS could cajole them. Adam Carrolla, Norm McDonald, David Spade. Ray Romano and Kevin James if you could get them.
Obviously, Anderson Cooper would be the perfect moderator, a modern-day John Daly, if he's not working too much. It would be nice to have a host with some currency who could attract decent mystery guests. Jeff Probst could be pretty good. I can see him messing with the panel.
-
[quote name=\'Neumms\' post=\'256142\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 09:35 AM\']Jessica Simpson. Because I like a little eye-candy, and she has to be pretty smart to play that dumb.[/quote]
It's entirely possible that she *is* just that dumb, too. It's not like she has the most mentally-taxing occupation.
-
[quote name=\'Matt Ottinger\' post=\'256133\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 07:32 AM\']Sorry, no. When I become a big, big star and get to produce my own panel show, I'm hiring a good host and putting myself on the panel. Thanks for the offer, though![/quote]
Yeah, I want Ottinger sitting next to me, so he can be Bennett Cerf to my Roger Price, as I draw half-pictures of people with large eyes and long noses and dudes in sombreros urinating.
-
[quote name=\'clemon79\' post=\'256144\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 01:31 PM\']Yeah, I want Ottinger sitting next to me, so he can be Bennett Cerf to my Roger Price, as I draw half-pictures of people with large eyes and long noses and dudes in sombreros urinating.[/quote]
I actually had you as the Henry Morgan to my Cullen, but that works too.
[quote name=\'clemon79\' post=\'256143\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 01:29 PM\']It's entirely possible that she *is* just that dumb, too. It's not like she has the most mentally-taxing occupation.[/quote]
She might lay it on a little thick these days because it works for her image, but yeah, I don't think she's a Mensa candidate putting on an act.
-
[quote name=\'Matt Ottinger\' post=\'256145\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 03:24 PM\'][quote name=\'clemon79\' post=\'256143\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 01:29 PM\']It's entirely possible that she *is* just that dumb, too. It's not like she has the most mentally-taxing occupation.[/quote]
She might lay it on a little thick these days because it works for her image, but yeah, I don't think she's a Mensa candidate putting on an act.
[/quote]
But she seems so available!
-
Coolio.
He's available.
-
[quote name=\'Matt Ottinger\' post=\'256145\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 01:24 PM\']She might lay it on a little thick these days because it works for her image[/quote]
I thought she already lost that weight.
-
Okay, here's my ideal panel for 2011:
Caroline Rhea, Martin Mull, Rosie O'Donnell, Montel Williams
Host: Pat Kiernan, Anderson Cooper or Tom Bergeron
-
[quote name=\'BillCullen1\' post=\'256172\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 10:24 PM\']Caroline Rhea, Martin Mull, Rosie O'Donnell, Montel Williams[/quote]I see two annoying females on here. I can absolutely see O'Donnell running Montel or Martin over.
-
I'd vote for Bonnie Hunt on any panel.
-
[quote name=\'BillCullen1\' post=\'256172\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 09:24 PM\']Okay, here's my ideal panel for 2011:
Caroline Rhea, Martin Mull, Rosie O'Donnell, Montel Williams
Host: Pat Kiernan, Anderson Cooper or Tom Bergeron[/quote]
Side note to your choice of Montel Williams: Not only do I agree with it, but if the director thinks we should see the panel en route to their seats, I'd like Montel to be treated exactly the same as the rest of the panel. (In case anyone doesn't know, Montel has MS.)
I could definitely see Cooper on TTTT or WML and Bergeron on IGAS. (I haven't seen Pat Kiernan, so I have no opinion there.)
-
[quote name=\'Jay Temple\' post=\'256193\' date=\'Feb 2 2011, 08:05 AM\']I'd like Montel to be treated exactly the same as the rest of the panel. (In case anyone doesn't know, Montel has MS.)[/quote]
I would think, much like Bill Cullen, that would be more of a decision for Montel to make than anyone.
-
[quote name=\'Modor\' post=\'256177\' date=\'Feb 2 2011, 12:54 AM\'][quote name=\'BillCullen1\' post=\'256172\' date=\'Feb 1 2011, 10:24 PM\']Caroline Rhea, Martin Mull, Rosie O'Donnell, Montel Williams[/quote]I see two annoying females on here. I can absolutely see O'Donnell running Montel or Martin over.
[/quote]
Rosie wouldn't be a bad WML? host, or I think she could be really good at TTTT, especially since her turns to question would be timed.
-
NPH, Samantha Harris, Nathan Lane and Oprah. Host: Ben Bailey.
-
Penn Gillette and Roger Ebert if he could talk again. Emma Thompson. Clive Anderson host