OK, Tommy, you've made a really good case that there IS a reason to know it, so I'll happily concede that point. But the other part still stands (and if I read your response, I think you agree with me). There's nothing to work out. You either know it or you're staring at a bunch of meaningless random numbers. The best WWTBAM questions are going to be more like the Beatles one, with plausible answers that inspire some amount of consideration.
In fact, in retrospect, that Beatles question was probably the best of the bunch. I think a lot of people (myself included) would lean toward "I Want To Hold Your Hand", which I'm now thinking was the LAST of the set.
From Gameshowguy2000:My MDQ would be too easy?
Hmm, even though some of us knew the answer to that one, including me, other people may not even know the answer.
That's true of ANY question, as Mr. Hutchinson noted. Specifically dealing with yours though, the poem is still very commonly called A Visit From St. Nicholas. That's not a particularly obscure fact at all. While it's true that any given person may or may not know any given piece of information, this is at best a middle-tier question.
Finally, whoserman said:There is a really good mdq on one of the WWTBAM cd-rom games...
Which book of the bible was the basis for the musical "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat"?
A: Joshua
B: Genesis
C: Revelation
D: Exodus
That's a nice question, but again not a particularly challenging one. Actual MDQ's on the show have sometimes been pretty easy as well, of course (such as Carpenter's Laugh-In question) but once again, this is not an obscure fact to anyone who spent any time in Sunday School.